No single carpet cleaning method wins every job, and a company that claims one does is usually describing the machine it already owns. We own one too, so read this with that in mind. The methods you'll run into around Florence are below, ours included, with the weak spots left in.
Four methods, compared
Hot-water extraction ("steam cleaning")
This is what most people picture. A truck-mounted or portable unit sprays hot water and detergent into the carpet, then pulls it back out with a strong vacuum wand. Done well, it flushes a lot of soil out of the pile, and it handles gritty, heavily used carpet better than its critics admit.
The trade-off is water. Even a good extraction job leaves carpet damp for several hours, and a sloppy one soaks the pad. The detergent is the other catch: if the rinse misses some of it, the leftover film grabs dirt and the traffic lanes go gray again faster than they should.
Very little actual steam is involved, by the way. It's hot water, and the name stuck anyway.
Shampooing
The oldest method on the list. A rotary machine works foaming shampoo into the carpet, and the dirty foam is extracted or left to dry and vacuumed up later. On the day, a badly soiled carpet can look dramatically better.
The problem shows up a few weeks later. Shampoo is soap, and soap left in the fibers stays sticky. Shampooed carpets tend to re-soil quickly, and spots you thought were gone seem to bloom back. It also puts a lot of water down, so drying can run into the evening.
Bonnet cleaning
You've seen this in offices and hotel hallways. A round pad soaked in cleaning solution spins across the carpet and picks soil off the top of the fibers. It's quick, it dries fast, and commercial buildings like it for those reasons.
It only works the surface, though. The pad doesn't reach far into the pile, and on a thick residential carpet it can push grit down while it polishes the tips. Fine for a lobby between deeper cleanings. A poor choice as the only thing a family room ever gets.
Foam products
Some cleaners lay down a thick foam, let it sit and trap soil, and then vacuum or extract it. Foam can help as a first pass on carpet that hasn't been touched in years. On its own, it leaves you counting on the vacuum to pull everything back out.
Low-moisture carbonated cleaning (ours)
Our solution has no soap in it. Carbonation does a lot of the lifting: the bubbles loosen soil from the fibers, and the machine pulls that soil out while putting very little water in. With nothing soapy left behind, there's no sticky film for new dirt to cling to, and most carpets are dry in about an hour.
Now the weak spots. A carpet that's been flooded is a restoration job, full stop. A pet spot that soaked through to the pad needs more than a surface-friendly clean, so for urine we switch to an enzyme treatment that goes down where the problem is (see how our enzyme odor treatment works). And on carpet with fifteen years of ground-in soil, the first cleaning will look a lot better but it won't look new.
Why drying time decided it for us
We chose a fast-drying method mostly because of what slow drying does to carpet in this part of South Carolina. Summers here are long and sticky. A carpet that stays wet overnight in July has nowhere to send the moisture.
Then a few things happen. Stains sitting down in the backing travel up the fibers as the carpet dries (cleaners call it wicking), so the spot you watched disappear on Monday is back by Thursday. The pad stays damp long after the face of the carpet feels dry, and damp pad smells musty. And the household spends the day tiptoeing around wet rooms with the furniture up on foil squares.
Less water going in means less water that has to come back out.
How to choose
If your lease says the carpets must be hot-water extracted at move-out, get them hot-water extracted. Landlords write that clause on purpose, and your deposit is on the line. If you manage an office, a bonnet service between deeper cleanings is a reasonable budget call.
For a lived-in home with kids, pets, and a long humid summer, we'd pick a method that leaves no residue and dries fast. That's our honest opinion, and yes, it's also what we sell.
Whoever you hire, ask two questions before they start. Is there soap or detergent in the solution? How long until I can walk on it? The answers tell you most of what you need to know about the method.
Our carpet cleaning page lays out how a visit goes: the tech walks the rooms with you, quotes the price before any equipment comes in, pre-treats the worst spots, and then cleans. The three-rooms-for-$88 offer is on the coupons page if you want to try it on your own traffic lanes.

